www.ditl.org

Now that we've done all the movies currently out, out of the winners, which was the best?

I'm going to go with "saving the whales".

Spock's death, with the destruction of the old Enterprise coming a close second.

Agreed on both.

Spocks death is without a doubt the best of Trek. Followed closely by the send-off in TUC.

Honourable mention to Enterprise burning up in the atmosphere, Shatner did an excellent job with Kirk's emotion in that scene.

Its a hard call, Spock's death and farewell was exceptionally well done but in the end I have to go with the signing off in TUC, it marked the end of an era and I very nearly tear up when I see it.

I didnt really feel anything when the Enterprise died. Spocks death was great though.

I'm going to mail a life-size Constitution-class replica to your house as soon as I have a few million to waste, Teaos. Then I'm going to make you eat it.

God how would I explane that to the neighbours.

Tell them you needed more quality in your diet.

If I wanted more quality I wouldnt have anything to do with TOS.

Walked right into that one.

EDIT: I mean both of us, from different perspectives.

"You have been, and always shall be, my friend. Live long and prosper."
The most moving scene in Trek. I cried when I first saw it at a drive in theater in Texas, when I was around 7 years old( Dad! Spock died! Waaaahhh!!). Of course, the scene that most sticks in my mind from that time is when the worm crawls out of Chekov's ear.

Spock's death. One of the greatest moments in the entire franchise.

Spock's death. Makes a man shed tears, that does.

Made me shed tears. Of course, then came the anger of "How could they do that!" Though, the death of the Enterprise was close.