Contest of champions

Meste17 · Post by **Meste17** » Tue Sep 24, 2024 4:47 am

Galaxy X (AGT version) vs Odyssey. Which class would win?

Tinadrin Chelnor · Post by **Tinadrin Chelnor** » Wed Sep 25, 2024 4:18 am

As the Galaxy-X doesn't exist in canon except in the alternate future timeline, and doesn't seem to have been built/retrofit in the Prime universe given we have never seen anything throughout Picard, etc, and we have never seen the Odyssey-class in battle in canon, there is no way to say canonically speaking.

However, given the Galaxy-X is a retrofit of an older vessel, whilst the Odyssey is a dreadnought/battleship that was purpose built (at least, that is the STO version, we don't know the capabilities of the canon version), I would likely give the edge to the Odyssey, and within my own Star Trek workings, that is the case, but again that is simply my won stuff, based off many sources, and not based on canon.

McAvoy · Post by **McAvoy** » Wed Sep 25, 2024 4:36 pm

Just going by what we know, the Galaxy class was a nearly 40 year old design if you go by the TNG Technical Manual. Sure was refitted with a big ass gun and other stuff but at the base still an old design. The Odyssey class on the other hand is a purpose built design that is much newer.

The question also applies to how Starfleet progressed it's technology since TNG as well. Does the All Good Things Enterprise have similar ships as the main timeline only that this Enterprise-D was survived?

Or in this timeline, Geordi finished the Picard Season 3 rebuilding of Enterprise-D and Admiral Riker took it and refitted her instead of having a Enterprise-F?