www.ditl.org

Sisko. He likes baseball.

Picard. The crew, the ship were pretty awesome.

There is only KIRK! The only being alive to make the Klingons think twice about starting a war!

Even if you were a redshirt, you were mourned. Kirk remembered your name. He recriminated himself.

Amen to that. I'd rather die for Kirk then serve under Janeway.

Rochey wrote:
Archer:
Pros: Uh, no idea. I'm sure there's a good quality there somewher....but I just can't think of any right now. At least your name will go down in the history books.

Went the first two seasons without losing a single crewmember. Never lost a crew member to his stupidity or to show how dangerous a situation is. That's the single best record in Trek I believe.

But he did tend to put them in needlessly dangerous situations for no reason at all. Just dumb luck no one died.

Indeed. And his track record of competance has been.....varying, to put it kindly.

He brought the Vulcans, Andorians, humans and Tellarites together. He revealed Sarek's true teachings and brought down the High Command.

He allowed millions of people to die because he failed high school biology and doesnt know what the hell evolution is.

He sent people into needlessly dangerous situations.

He's a racist.

He's a sh*t explorer which is what he was supposed to be.

You can add "hypocrite" to that list, too.

Teaos wrote:But he did tend to put them in needlessly dangerous situations for no reason at all. Just dumb luck no one died.

Sometimes that's all you need

I don't blame Archer though, he was just a victim of the times. He should have been leading a attack squadron or patroling the border. Not jumping around known and unknown space hoping for the best. Besides, he has two of the best looking women in trek with him. That has to count for something.

Deepcrush wrote:I don't blame Archer though, he was just a victim of the times. He should have been leading a attack squadron or patroling the border. Not jumping around known and unknown space hoping for the best. Besides, he has two of the best looking women in trek with him. That has to count for something.

That's odd...I don't remember Jadzia or Ezri being on Enterprise

They were on at different times so they don't count.