What just happened in those last few paragraphs?
We came across the Cardassian freighter, and found that it had been destroyed by Federation weapons. Cue shock and horror from the crew.
While we're gawking at the ship, five Tholian cruisers turned up and reached the conclusion that the
Daystrom and the
Bangalore blew up the freighter. Naturaly, they did not take kindly to this.
Now, we seem to have some new friends in the area, also. A bunch of Caitans on a modified
Freedom class Federaton ship. Given that they're in a Federation ship, I think we can conclude that they blew up the Cardassian freighter. They seem to be hell-bent on taking down the Tholian cruisers, and may have blown the freighter up for bait.
Also, given the Caitain's remarks near the end, I think we can assume that either the Tholian Assembly has been commiting genocide against the Caitan race, or M'Real is about to have a family reunion.
Anyway, on to the more pressing matter of what the hell we're going to do. We have two options: fight, or try resolving this peacefully.
I would strongly suggest taking the diplomatic way out. Assuming these cruisers are of the type that DarkOmen designed for us, then the
Daystrom and the
Bangalore are going to get horrificaly raped against five of them. Given that the Freedom class' overall strenght is only rated at 423, the
Fifth Column is going to be swated out of the sky like a fly. Basicaly, we have no hope in a fight, and the Caitans seem more than willing to let us die if they can take down some of the Tholian ships.
Even asside from the massive disparity in strength here, we have other reasons not to fight. I doubt the Captain wants to start a full-scale war between the Assembly and the Federation, which could very well happen if a small-scale fleet action broke out inside Tholian space.
Then there's the fact that Rochey probably won't be too pleased shooting at his own ships, and he could probably make things very difficult during and after any fight.
Basicaly, any fight would be a diplomatic disaster, as well as getting us all horribly mauled in combat.
My recomendation is to try to convince the Tholians that we didn't do it. The fact that we have authorisation to be in the area, and are investigating such attacks may help persuade them to back down for a moment or to. And really, we only need a moment. Once the
Fifth Column decloaks and starts it's rather poorly thought out fight, the Tholians will probably realise that we had nothing to do with it, and go after the Caitans.
I see events progressing like this:
We try to convince the Tholians we didn't do it. They don't believe us at first, but are convinced when the
Column appears and starts attacking them. Before the ship is destroyed, we manage to beam the crew over. The Tholians don't realise that, and wander off, happy at having blown something up. Back on the
Daystrom M'Real gets the shock of her life.
Should I start writing something along these lines up?