www.ditl.org

Rochey wrote:Whichever one gets past plastic packing crates.

"None of the above," then?

RK_Striker_JK_5 wrote:I'd still like to see a worst captain's decision series, like the best decision one.

not a worst one, there would be no poll, it'd be a unanamous decision:

Janeway blowing up the Caretakers Array

"None of the above," then?

Can't get much worse then that one. Although I'm not too fond of Picard's decision to drop the cloak after the E-D escaped from inside the asteroid in "The Pegasus", either. Why not just slip away and leave Tomalak sitting there for days waiting for a signal? The amusement value alone would have been worth it.

Terminal "nice guy syndrome."

When they got back to Starbase Wherever, they could have hailed him and said "What are you still doing there?" or something. That's the sort of thing Kirk would have done.

Not sure it was Tomalok in that episode - shame, he's a great character.

I was watching the Opinionated Voyager Episdoe Review site's review of "The Caretaker" last night - its great. I especially love the bit with the tricorders

*about half a dozen Starfleet officers crowd together, all with their tricorders out*

"Hey, hey, can we get some more tricorders over here? I think we missed an atom!"

Love that site.

Lt. Staplic wrote:

RK_Striker_JK_5 wrote:I'd still like to see a worst captain's decision series, like the best decision one.

not a worst one, there would be no poll, it'd be a unanamous decision:

Janeway blowing up the Caretakers Array

No. Do it like the 'best captain's decisions' one.

One week, Kirk. Then Picard, followed by Sisko, Janeway and then Archer. Then we take the winners and match them up.

I think it's still safe to say that Janeway would win the question of the ultimate stupid move, though.

We've discussed it enough to get a concenses on how we on the forum feel, BUT, those not participating, who knows? They may or may not have different opinions.

And what's the concensus, that Janeway's the dumbest of them all? Yeah, natch, but come on. The other four have had their 'hall of shame' moments as well.

I doubt there will be much competiton is the stupid decision contest.